This episode of Cinemavino kicks off a limited series, in which we take a new look at old movies. To qualify, a film must be a stink-bomb that got good reviews, or a great movie that got dumped on. Oddly enough, Waterworld falls somewhere in between those goalposts. Most critics kicked its ass, but there were a few prominent exceptions: Leonard Maltin gave it three stars. Roger Ebert was generous enough for two and a half.